Coral Smith, 44

Season 5: Battle of the Seasons

13

Camila Nakagawa, 35

Season 22: Battle of the Exes

14

Hunter Barfield, 30

Season 32: Final Reckoning

15

Darrell Taylor, 44

Season 7: The Gauntlet, 8: The Inferno, 10: The Inferno II, 12: Fresh Meat

16

Evelyn Smith, 36

Season 14: The Inferno 3, 16: The Island

17

Sarah Patterson, 37

Season 26: Battle of the Exes II, 28: Rivals III

18

Kenny Santucci, 40

Season 14: The Inferno 3, 16: The Island, 18: The Ruins

19

Sean Duffy, 52

Season 1: All Stars

20

Sarah Greyson, 41

Season 7: The Gauntlet

21

Mark Long, 52

Season 2: Real World vs. Road Rules, 6: Battle of the Sexes

22

Veronica Portillo, 46

Season 3: Challenge 2000, 7: The Gauntlet, 8: The Inferno

23

Cara Zavaleta, 43

Season 7: The Gauntlet

24

Abram Boise, 40

Season 8: The Inferno

25

Emily Schromm, 35

Season 24: Rivals II

26

Johanna Botta, 40

Season 15: The Gauntlet III

27